Game Theory: FNAF, Return To The Pit (3 New FNAF Theories)

SUBSCRIBE to Never Miss A Game Theory! ►

Check out Rhett \u0026 Link's podcast 'Ronstadt' FREE on Spotify \u0026 Apple Podcasts!
Apple Podcast:

Welcome back to MatPat has too many FNAF theories, that he needs to put multiple in an episode! Today we are going to cover 3 more short Five Nights At Freddy's theories, focusing mainly on the new books. From more information on the ever important Cassidy, to William Afton's time travel shenanigans, there is a LOT to cover! Let's dive into this time traveling ball pit, shall we?

Find the game here ►
SUBSCRIBE to Catch all the Theories! ►

0:00 - Theory #1
7:40 - Theory #2
12:53 - Theory #3

Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ►

FNAF, The FINAL Timeline ►►
FNAF, The Monster We MISSED! ►►
FNAF This Theory Changes Everything ►
FNAF, You Were Meant To Lose ►
FNAF 6, No More Secrets ►

Writer: Matthew Patrick
Editors: Tyler Mascola, Pedro Freitas, Alex "Sedge" Sedgwick, and Dan "Cybert" Seibert
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman


  • Mr. Maxim
    Mr. Maxim2 godzin temu


  • ProBro
    ProBro2 godzin temu

    12:37 what? why

  • the rascal
    the rascal2 godzin temu

    lol furys rage is like final fight

  • Saturn Games
    Saturn Games2 godzin temu

    Y'all should do one more petscop theory

  • Danny K 2001
    Danny K 20012 godzin temu

    Theory 3....this is one of the ones that has me convinced MatPat is losing his grip, and is just pumping this stuff out for clicks. Guessing he skimmed over the parts in Frights 7 and 8's epilogues where Jake purges Afton's infection, and a doctor later tells Larson that he HAD an infection, but it had been all burned away and he was clear to go home. The theory was dead before it got off the ground.

    DH NAPPY2 godzin temu

    Man... my head

  • gaming few 1234
    gaming few 12342 godzin temu

    Into the pit song

  • Qwizly Videoz
    Qwizly Videoz2 godzin temu

    The moment you said. “The wet spring lock suit calmed down on your subscription feed” I got an e-mail

  • Lucas Cherry
    Lucas Cherry2 godzin temu

    I think Hudson is the first night guard and Michael is the 2nd night guard

  • RainbowGamer
    RainbowGamer2 godzin temu

    With what has come out about Scott I hope this is the last fnaf video.....

  • Null


    2 godzin temu

    Hopefully not. Shouldn't matter.

    SPLEENS-THE-CAT1232 godzin temu

    Oml all the views in only 22 hours

  • Itay Broitman
    Itay Broitman2 godzin temu

    Springbony is not william afton.......

  • 5564


    2 godzin temu

    @Itay Broitman Not trying to be mean or anything but William got into a spring bonnie spring lock and died

  • Itay Broitman

    Itay Broitman

    2 godzin temu

    Michael is springbony

  • Very Delectable Dairy Product
    Very Delectable Dairy Product2 godzin temu

    when im postor sus pision

  • * stranger 666 Karma*
    * stranger 666 Karma*2 godzin temu


  • Red•Moon
    Red•Moon2 godzin temu

    The write of 87 got me🤣🤣

  • Meme Gamer
    Meme Gamer2 godzin temu

    I got the 8th book

  • maheen minsa
    maheen minsa2 godzin temu

    I thought the game really came..

  • PizzaOfzo Games
    PizzaOfzo Games2 godzin temu

    Maybe... There are 2 timelines. the first timeline starts with the games etc. (exept vr) all the things happens. Oswalds travel trough time and saw the murder. He spread the rumours that in security breach they're talking about. Larson prevent the murder from happening and goes back to the present. Here the new timeline starts. Oswald spread the rumours and the fnaf company made a game. But then somehow. Larson's glitchtap virus ends up in the game. (i know that it came from chips but i'm just speculating) and then the cult of glitchtrap starts. So let's line it up Timeline 1 all fnaf games from 1 to pizza simulator. all the books. Timeline 2 Vr and security breach. (I'm a noob in theorizing. It's just speculations and probaly alot of language mistakes in this comment)

  • Josiah Jimenez
    Josiah Jimenez2 godzin temu

    remember when FNaF was about a guy that killed children? Yeah, me neither.

  • TheOneAndOnly Godzilla
    TheOneAndOnly Godzilla2 godzin temu

    Oh boy, here we go again

  • Cici Cancer
    Cici Cancer2 godzin temu

    sorry bro this is the worst theory you've made

  • mino
    mino2 godzin temu

    theory: matpat will probably stop fnaf videos after scott cawthon was revealed to be based

  • Tom
    Tom2 godzin temu

    Scott: does anything that’s fnaf related Matpat: *THEORY TIME.*

  • Wisdom of the pup
    Wisdom of the pup2 godzin temu

    11:25 I never thought I would hear Matt patt swear again (btw some of you might think that “damn” isn’t a swear word but everyone has their own opinion and I also don’t watch GT live so I don’t know if he’s sworn on there)

  • Burning Gojira
    Burning Gojira2 godzin temu

    Damm i forgot fnaf existed

  • Beebrain Music
    Beebrain Music2 godzin temu

    Why so much fnaf;-; beating a decomposed horse 🐎 🤔 😳 🙄 😐 😕 🐎

  • Luxurius Litten
    Luxurius Litten2 godzin temu

    Ah yes time for another addition of matpat going mentally insane

  • Michael Connolly
    Michael Connolly2 godzin temu

    Nice video

  • Michael Connolly
    Michael Connolly2 godzin temu

    Read the hello neighbor books

  • Michael Connolly
    Michael Connolly2 godzin temu

    Please do more fazbear frights book theories

  • Foxyfredbear500 Hotwheels
    Foxyfredbear500 Hotwheels2 godzin temu

    Hello am I the one that thinks purple guy is Sus

  • tree
    tree2 godzin temu

    fnaf like: i always come back

  • vintran gamer
    vintran gamer2 godzin temu

    Not true

  • Zalama
    Zalama2 godzin temu

    Imagine scott was going to do this but then he saw this video and changed the lore

  • tyto
    tyto2 godzin temu

    When will the next petscop video come out? I’ve been passently waiting, for nothing!

  • CultureFreak


    2 godzin temu


  • TheRealSpicymonkey
    TheRealSpicymonkey2 godzin temu

    Jessica tang Is the voice of tape girl and will play the voice of Vanny

  • Doll Chan
    Doll Chan2 godzin temu

    mini theory? what if tape girl in help wanted is vanny ?

  • Foxyplayz139
    Foxyplayz1392 godzin temu

    7:28 it's not 2 lights rather the one light in the mask is brighter than the other masks since all the other masks have this one glow ring in their mask so if their were two there would be two glowing rings instead of one and i'm pretty sure the reason its so bright is to show the player that golden freddy is there and who the heck is golden bonnie?

  • Random artist Hi
    Random artist Hi2 godzin temu


  • Rhylek
    Rhylek2 godzin temu

    i stand with scott!

  • Zachary Kalmus
    Zachary Kalmus2 godzin temu

    Am I the only one that saw the community darkest timeline reference

  • Jester of the carnival
    Jester of the carnival2 godzin temu

    I have a theory that what ever you gives you trauma you will see them around fazbear frights, it explains the phantoms and hudson from what we found hearing his teacher and seeing his stepdad and see faith while chica parts was in the vents with him

  • Dark Nimbus
    Dark Nimbus2 godzin temu


  • Lophray
    Lophray2 godzin temu

    Ok dad

  • kareness
    kareness2 godzin temu

    we r back

  • Lenschagor _
    Lenschagor _2 godzin temu

    like this game is so old but matpat : WAIT THERE IS SOMETHING

  • SleepyKat
    SleepyKat2 godzin temu

    Nobody: Water drop: I'm about to end this man's whole career

    STILL2 godzin temu

    Narrative of Self is the result of a feedback loop between “Separate Self” & Cosmos🎈

  • Creativity and Friends
    Creativity and Friends2 godzin temu

    I watch Good Mythical Morning!!! They're awesome, and so are you MatPat!

  • Tsuyu Asui
    Tsuyu Asui2 godzin temu

    Final: •Coming at the end of a series Game theory: That’s not right now is it

  • • strawberry Simp •
    • strawberry Simp •2 godzin temu

    Something that doesn’t sit right with me is micheal afton. Sure it makes since that he’s the one we play as throughout the game. But what about foxy? We’ve confirmed that indeed foxy has a Michael afton inside him so how is Michael afton still going through game to game as a rotting corpse? Their can’t be two Michael afton’s. I believe that there’s something here. Something that we missed. Maybe I’m wrong on this and just confused but I just don’t get it

  • Vishwanath Bhadauriya
    Vishwanath Bhadauriya2 godzin temu

    I always wanted to see you put the IMMA GONNA END THIS MANS WHOLE CAREER meme forever

  • spread spread
    spread spread2 godzin temu

    Why did you have to do that do a scribblenauts asset?

  • spread spread

    spread spread

    2 godzin temu

    Poor scribblenauts asset

  • Vexon
    Vexon2 godzin temu

    Oh god i am totaly lost in the lore of the books and the games😔

  • Victor Remon Quevedo
    Victor Remon Quevedo2 godzin temu

    hah, so you like fnaf mmmphh? name ALL the lore MatPat: hold my merch

  • Lthiddensniper
    Lthiddensniper2 godzin temu

    'I'm shoving theories in everywhere' -MatPat 2021

  • Stair Worse Studios
    Stair Worse Studios2 godzin temu

    Babe, wake up! Matpat posted a new FNAF theory!

  • Dead End
    Dead End2 godzin temu

    Here’s my theory: you dont actually play as Mike in the games, but the detective or the Stitchwraith who’s been time travelling with the ballpit. Just a random thought, but it’s pretty interesting.

  • JaredTheBro
    JaredTheBro2 godzin temu

    12:50 You know the editors are super dedicated when they make a thumbnail that's not even the actual thumbnail

  • Forzen Knight
    Forzen Knight2 godzin temu

    This is a theory that I don’t know if it was talked about or confirmed or if it was common sense and no one talked about this, but something always stood out: how did William Afton survive getting trapped in the springlocks I know it was like, “he had an iron will to live” or something, but what if it was a different force? A spirit keeping afton alive so when the time comes, Cassidy can torture afton. I know this sounds dumb but this is a decent theory that I can come up with, sooooo enjoy and think about it I guess? Have a good day🙂

  • Sadam Yousafzai
    Sadam Yousafzai2 godzin temu


  • shidded and fawded
    shidded and fawded2 godzin temu

    ty for making fnaf mattpatt

  • Jayden Lopez
    Jayden Lopez2 godzin temu

    Remember when this was a series of horror games….good times

  • Miguel Jaramillo
    Miguel Jaramillo2 godzin temu

    How could this happen im so good looking

  • Emma Heart
    Emma Heart2 godzin temu

    "after math of a pandemic" *cries in Canada where most of us have only just gotten our first shot*

  • iazuya ludo
    iazuya ludo2 godzin temu


  • Dominic Peca
    Dominic Peca2 godzin temu

    Water droplet: I m a b o u t t o e n d t h i s m a n s w h o l e c a r e e r

  • Dashy Z
    Dashy Z2 godzin temu

    Babe wake up, new GT FNAF Theory

  • StormingBlade
    StormingBlade2 godzin temu

    It is Sergio's Lucky Day this is spooky since my name is Sergio 😂

    SLIMY-not-cool THE-BELGIAN-GUY2 godzin temu

    Adkin Atkin is Afton But maybe the D T has a meaning?

  • fuzzywuzzyuwu _
    fuzzywuzzyuwu _2 godzin temu

    No better way to spend my birthday then with MatPat!

  • Kayplays I play games
    Kayplays I play games2 godzin temu

    Ok but in the trailer for security breach Balloras song is playing in the background that might give some of you (and matpat) something to think about

  • BlakJakTheyShouldKnow
    BlakJakTheyShouldKnow2 godzin temu


  • Sonicmantee277 Plays
    Sonicmantee277 Plays2 godzin temu

    Hey mat pat uuu I don't know how to tell you this but DDLC IS GOING TO HAVE NEW LORE TO UNCOVER ON JUNE 30TH

  • horace andy
    horace andy2 godzin temu

    The overconfident care physically learn because cupcake cellularly dry opposite a omniscient beech. paltry, hapless sousaphone

  • Memeber Berry
    Memeber Berry2 godzin temu

    You have many options , many games house hundreds of theories, yet you still do the same topics over and over.

  • Memeber Berry

    Memeber Berry

    2 godzin temu

    Do somthing current, not fnaf for your whole life. There are new theroriest emerging from the shadows if you keep up your capitalistic values you will lose your fans to them.

  • the real Clark Stanley
    the real Clark Stanley2 godzin temu

    Matthew you can swim my secret pit anytime

  • •CaЯsoп•
    •CaЯsoп•2 godzin temu

    “That’s great” was that you..

  • SeaMoose
    SeaMoose2 godzin temu

    I'm surprised their isn't any SCPs relating to FnaF

  • Sparkling Dimond
    Sparkling Dimond2 godzin temu

    I wonder if fury rage is one of the arcade games that’s in security breach

  • Chase Anderson
    Chase Anderson2 godzin temu

    Can’t believe that a drop of water started all of fnaf 3

  • It’s over anakin I have the High ground
    It’s over anakin I have the High ground2 godzin temu

    The books feel like weird fan fiction

  • terfare fopiqbum
    terfare fopiqbum2 godzin temu

    The nine pencil frequently expect because menu unintentionally preach barring a deadpan morning. distinct, upset maria

  • purnima dasari
    purnima dasari2 godzin temu

    I'm sad that the theory ended :C

  • JustBread OG
    JustBread OG2 godzin temu


  • duck wert
    duck wert2 godzin temu

    How did fnaf go to ghosts and souls to time travel

  • funnyeditz
    funnyeditz2 godzin temu

    MATT PATT YOU HAVE TO HEAR THIS doki doki literature club is comming back! 19 hours ago they posted a new trailer with new upcomming things we need to see if there is more to discover about this game!

  • fallen king
    fallen king 2 godzin temu

    very intresting

  • Chelsea Wakefield
    Chelsea Wakefield3 godzin temu


  • spone fack
    spone fack3 godzin temu

    Yyyyweeeeeessssss finaly

  • Chase Boucher
    Chase Boucher3 godzin temu

    I just realized how far we’ve come from a scary game

  • Kyle Vogel
    Kyle Vogel3 godzin temu

    Why have I not seen any comments about the goatee on Scott when Matt talks about “The Darkest Timeline” as in referring to Community and the darkest timeline gag

  • Daisy Reid
    Daisy Reid3 godzin temu

    Anyone else find it mad disrespectful that fazbear entertainment used the death of children to make more money lol

  • Ghost
    Ghost3 godzin temu

    Your videos are always amazing

  • New Earth Animation
    New Earth Animation3 godzin temu

    the ball pit might not have anything to do with time travel but the ball pit its self is the important thing. the place where Afton made his first kill or began walking down the path he chose. it might be a place that holds and emotional importance to Afton or his victims. but that is just a stab in the dark.

  • SA64
    SA643 godzin temu

    MatPat FNAF the finale MatPat Comes with a another theory

  • Tarquinn Matthew
    Tarquinn Matthew3 godzin temu

    So mat what’s your thoughts on the Scott Cawthon donation controversy?

  • Hamsti Manent
    Hamsti Manent3 godzin temu

    I like the Community reference at 14:07. Even the goatee!

  • funky plushie
    funky plushie3 godzin temu